Photoshop is dead, but not because of ArtCraft
Adobe isn't going anywhere, but their pro creative apps like Photoshop won't survive the next decade.

For years now, AI has been reshaping life and work at a pace that’s been hard for me to wrap my head around. But what turned my head last month was ArtCraft. ArtCraft is an opensource project that recreated Adobe’s most popular apps using AI. PhotoCraft is Photoshop. VectorCraft is Illustrator. FilmCraft is Premiere Pro. LightCraft is Lightroom. You get the point. In total, ArtCraft created 7 free clones in the image of the ones you and your company have paid Adobe for, for years.
It’s not just the Adobe creative apps. Beyond ArtCraft, AI is being used to reverse engineer and recreate video games at rapid speed so they become playable on any device. The entire PlayStation console experience was recreated inside of Roblox and the people behind ArtCraft have released clones of professional apps from Microsoft Word, to AutoCAD, to Pro Tools.
These recreations are not perfect. They are not polished. They have a ton of bugs. But some of them work well enough that you can use them as basic stand-ins for their counterparts…and the team behind them built these Adobe creative app clones in just ten days with AI. The same Claude Code you’ve been using to vibe code a website can also reverse engineer and rebuild professional-grade software that took thousands of engineers to build and maintain. Not long after the release of the Creative Cloud clones, pronouncements of Adobe’s demise started. Obviously, they don’t know how Adobe makes its money. I know and see on a regular basis how Adobe roots itself deeply into the corporate enterprise, far beyond the apps that creative professionals use. Adobe is also quite familiar with this kind of fight, having warred against piracy for decades.
You won’t see me joining the chorus of doomers singing the songs of Adobe’s supposedly imminent bankruptcy, but it is almost certain that within a decade’s time their mature professional creative apps will be abandoned and eventually relegated to the dustbin of software history. The Innovator’s Dilemma tells us why.

I’ve been reading that book, The Innovator’s Dilemma: When New Technologies Cause Great Firms to Fail by Clayton Christensen and it’s through his lens that I see Adobe and many other media and software companies. The book asserts that great firms don’t fail because they don’t innovate. Rather, it’s because they don’t and often can’t embrace the kind of disruptive innovation that upsets their existing customers. So progress shoots past them. The book gives many examples of corporate titans that eventually fell victim to the innovator’s dilemma, from IBM to Sears.
It’s an easy framework that maps where Adobe is and where it will be facing challenges. Yes, Adobe is embracing AI and incorporating it into apps like Generative Fill in Photoshop and Generative Extend in Premiere Pro. Adobe’s AI audio cleanup tool, Enhance Speech, is amazing. I never want to go back to a world where it doesn’t exist. But what Adobe has done so far doesn’t add up to disruptive innovation. These incremental improvements cater to my old habits, not the new ones I’m discovering. That’s precisely why these apps we’ve been using for decades will be abandoned.
I’ve been using Adobe’s creative apps now for more than 15 years. I’ve used them to create memes and motion graphics. I’ve used them to sound mix short films. And I’ve used them to edit feature films. I don’t see a future where I will need or perhaps even want to use those apps anymore. Similar to how AI changed how I code, it is also changing the tools I use to tell stories.
Lately I’ve been doing some video editing. Think talking-head style, with B-Roll and text/ graphic motion. This was my first real foray into AI-based workflows for video editing with Premiere Pro. With AI working as my assistant editor, I was able to significantly cut my time to edit certain videos. And I keep discovering new efficiencies.
But I’m still using Premiere Pro for that, so how can I be so certain I’m going to be able to abandon it? Right now, I’m leveraging the unofficial MCP for Premiere Pro extension to have Claude handle some of the tasks that I usually have to tackle as I’m going through a video edit. MCP servers, especially used in this way, are more of an intermediate step on the way to something else. The APIs the MCP service for Premiere Pro is built on aren’t low-level enough to expose the full potential of precise video editing to agents. The same is true of APIs for Photoshop and other mature professional creative apps. None of them were built with agents in mind.
I became a true believer in the demise of Photoshop, Premiere Pro and the other pro creative apps when I needed to figure out the most efficient way to handle a large amount of text motion graphics for a video. I needed to choose between using After Effects, Canva, or motion effects directly in Premiere Pro. I chose none of those options.
In just a few minutes Claude whipped up a custom app to create exactly what I needed, complete with all the right content and with enough flexibility for me to tweak the timing, animation, content, and layout to my liking. No futzing through layers or researching workflows. I got only and exactly what I needed to get the job done. And the time it took me to complete a series of videos was cut by more than half thanks to this tool Claude vibe coded in a few minutes.
This is the innovator’s dilemma that Adobe finds itself in. While it spends untold millions investing in generative AI for decades-old apps, frontier AI companies and startups are leapfrogging them by allowing creatives to near-instantly build the tools they need to create at will. This leaves nothing for Adobe to offer as far as their popular creative apps are concerned. And creating custom tools is just the start.
Agents can work across multiple systems and disciplines simultaneously. They can be dispatched to handle the boring tasks creatives need to do (like billing) at the same time they’re organizing source files and exporting an asset. And creatives themselves can build exactly how they want all these things to happen. This is why the AI underground is so exciting. Creators are not just taking what’s given to them. They are building their own tailor-made solutions. This is the kind of disruptive innovation that kills companies that can’t keep up.
A YouTuber I follow posted a video last month explaining how he uses Claude to edit his videos. Unlike my workflow, which is based around Premiere Pro, his workflow sidesteps video editing and motion graphics desktop apps altogether. Instead, Claude drives everything. It produces his videos, cut logically with detailed edits, and with advanced motion graphics implemented.
I’m sure for him Claude doesn’t always get it right on the first try. And it’s doubtful that the appless workflow scales to detailed professional-grade work today, but that’s the innovator’s dilemma at play again. Christensen argues in his book that new disruptive technological innovation is almost never up to par with the mature solution. But disruptive innovations are cheaper, simpler and more convenient (also faster), and that almost always brings radical change of the kind that incumbents like Adobe can hardly react to even when they see it coming a mile away.
So yes, we can start writing the eulogy of Photoshop, wax poetic about how we built a monster of a composition in After Effects, and reminisce about the frame-fudging we did in Premiere Pro to get the edit to feel just right because those days are largely going to be behind us. You won’t see me shedding tears. I welcome this future with open arms, ideally with open-weight models so nothing gets in the way of what we can build. After all, I’m a creative technologist and I want nothing more than for creatives to start building their own tools again.